FYI, I am using Google Chrome.
I've done some more troubleshooting myself, and found that it's the Favourite system acting odd.
I had The Imp as a favourite, and was getting the "Favourite!" tag on mouseover of Charming 1 & 2, but not on The Imp.
I un-favored The Imp, and now the links are acting as they should.
My guess is that something is interacting between when you favourite something, and whatever next link you click.
Hope that helps.